West CoastReefers
๐Ÿ’šDonate๐Ÿ Home
๐Ÿ’ฌCommunity Forums
๐Ÿ‘‹Introductions๐ŸŒบCoral๐Ÿ Fish๐Ÿต๏ธAnemones & Clownfishโš™๏ธEquipment๐ŸงชWater Chemistry๐Ÿฆ€General๐Ÿ”งDIY๐Ÿ“ทPhotography๐ŸŒฑBeginner Help๐ŸชLocal Fish Stores๐ŸคSponsorsโญVendor Reviews๐Ÿ›‹๏ธLounge๐Ÿ’กSite Feedback
๐Ÿ“…Events๐Ÿ†Contests๐ŸกBuilds๐Ÿ Marketplace๐Ÿ”จAuctions๐Ÿ—๏ธStand Builder๐ŸงฎCalculators๐Ÿ‘ฅMembers
โ†’Sign in
Sponsors
๐ŸคBecome a sponsor
AboutTerms & rulesPrivacyContact
๐Ÿ Home๐Ÿ’ฌForums๐Ÿ Market๐Ÿ”จAuctionsโ†’Sign in
๏ผ‹ New threadSign in
AboutยทNonprofitยทDonateยทGiveaway winnersยทTerms & rulesยทPrivacy policyยทContactยทinfo@westcoastreefers.com
ยฉ 2026 West Coast Reefers
@reefinement
๐Ÿ˜Žย Coolย Kidsโ›ฐ๏ธAquascaper
Joined Aug 202618 posts75 pts๐Ÿ“ OC, CA
Water ChemistryยทOct 29ยท๐Ÿ‘ 129#1

Whatโ€™s Your Go-To Reef Salt & Why?๐Ÿชธ๐Ÿง‚

Curious what everyoneโ€™s go-to reef salt is and why! Iโ€™m looking to start mixing my own saltwater and have been comparing Tropic Marin Pro Reef, Aquaforest, and a few others. My biggest priorities are consistency between batches, stable parameters (especially alk, calcium, and magnesium), and overall quality. What salt are you currently using? Have you experienced any inconsistencies or issues, or has it been rock solid for you? Letโ€™s hear it! ๐Ÿ‘€
13

Replies (13)

Jump to newest โ†“
  1. @BackbayReef
    SCRM๐Ÿ˜Žย Coolย Kids๐Ÿง Reef Guru
    Joined May 2026319 posts1,252 ptsโ˜…5.0(2)
    ๐Ÿ”ง Build Contributor
    Oct 29#2
Reply
Share your experienceโ€ฆ
Sign in to join the conversationSign in โ†’
Good topic - Iโ€™m wondering the same as well! Iโ€™ve been using Red Sea Blue commercial 200gal bag (from Seaside) for years. Itโ€™s very consistent and doesnโ€™t leave a residue. Alk comes in around 8ish, which matches my current params. Iโ€™m super happy with it. However, Iโ€™ve just implemented a AWC 1.5wks ago and will likely burn through a 200gal bag every month. At ~$90/bag, this can add up fast! Iโ€™m thinking about switching to IO Reef Crystal to save a few bucks. Curious to hear everyoneโ€™s feedback. I heard that Alk is 9โ€™ish?

โ€” /yolo

  • @reefinement
    ๐Ÿ˜Žย Coolย Kidsโ›ฐ๏ธAquascaperOP
    Joined Aug 202618 posts75 pts๐Ÿ“ OC, CA
    Oct 29#3
    @BackbayReef wrote: Good topic - Iโ€™m wondering the same as well! Iโ€™ve been using Red Sea Blue commercial 200gal bag (from Seaside) for years. Itโ€™s very consistent and doesnโ€™t leave a residue. Alk comes in around 8ish, which matches my current params. Iโ€™m super happy with it. However, Iโ€™ve just implemented a AWC 1.5wks ago and will likely burn through a 200gal bag every month. At ~$90/bag, this can add up fast! Iโ€™m thinking about switching to IO Reef Crystal to save a few bucks. Curious to hear everyoneโ€™s feedback. I heard that Alk is 9โ€™ish?
    Great input! Super curious to hear everyoneโ€™s as well! Thanks for taking the time to share your insight!
  • @mescobar
    SCRM๐Ÿ˜Žย Coolย Kids๐ŸŒธPolyp Whisperer
    Joined Aug 202632 posts183 ptsโ˜…5.0(1)
    ๐Ÿ”ง Build Contributor
    Oct 29#4
    Iโ€™m thinking about switching to IO Reef Crystal to save a few bucks. Curious to hear everyoneโ€™s feedback. I heard that Alk is 9โ€™ish?
    My experience has been that RC is dirty and leaves a ton of residue and takes a while to mix. I've seem some discussions of old school reefers who used to swear by RC now moving away from it. Their reasoning being the inconsistency - alk that ranges from 9 all the way to 13 dKH. It seems as if IO doesn't really care to ICP test or quality control their batches, this probably helps keep the cost down. For auto-water-changes, the salter water probably matters less since you are doing ~1% water change a day. So inconsistent saltwater won't matter too much if you already do additive dosing. If doing AWC anyway, save a couple more bucks and go with IO (purple lid) over RC (orange lid). You don't need the elevated alk/mag/ca that comes with RC.

    โ€” Stay Salty

  • @mescobar
    SCRM๐Ÿ˜Žย Coolย Kids๐ŸŒธPolyp Whisperer
    Joined Aug 202632 posts183 ptsโ˜…5.0(1)
    ๐Ÿ”ง Build Contributor
    Oct 29#5
    As far as salt, I typically go with whatever is on sale during black friday and matches my alk of 8-9 dKH. I'm still working through HW Marinemix Reefer salt which has worked out really well. I appreciate that it is a synthetic salt so its much easier for the manufacturer to control what elements are going into the batches.

    โ€” Stay Salty

  • @ktran
    SCRM๐Ÿ˜Žย Coolย Kids๐Ÿง Reef Guru
    Joined May 2026203 posts835 ptsโ˜…5.0(1)๐Ÿ“ Tustin, CA
    ๐Ÿ”ง Build Contributor
    Oct 29#6
    Instant ocean just cause its cheap and my corals don't care

    โ€” Always keeping it simple

  • @CenCalReefer559
    ๐Ÿ˜Žย Coolย Kids๐Ÿค“Coral Nerd
    Joined Aug 202610 posts51 pts๐Ÿ“ Fresno, CA
    ๐Ÿ”ง Build Contributor
    Oct 29#7
    Same as @ktran, instant ocean. Cheap and always in stock.
  • @joeoliver
    SCRM๐Ÿ˜Žย Coolย Kids๐ŸŒธPolyp Whisperer
    Joined Aug 202633 posts155 ptsโ˜…5.0(1)๐Ÿ“ Diamond Bar, CA
    Oct 29#8
    currently using Tropic Marin. I also bought several boxes of nyos pure when it was on sale and it worked fine. I do AWCs and no issues with either.
  • @WIshntoboutside
    SCRM๐Ÿ˜Žย Coolย Kidsโ›ฐ๏ธAquascaper
    Joined Aug 202617 posts86 pts๐Ÿ“ Riverside
    Oct 29#9
    Fauna Marin or Tropic Marin. Any thoughts we can make this one a pole?

    โ€” Help enjoy the reefing community

  • @reefinement
    ๐Ÿ˜Žย Coolย Kidsโ›ฐ๏ธAquascaperOP
    Joined Aug 202618 posts75 pts๐Ÿ“ OC, CA
    Oct 29#10
    @WIshntoboutside wrote: Fauna Marin or Tropic Marin. Any thoughts we can make this one a pole?
    Do it!
  • @reefcat
    ๐Ÿ˜Žย Coolย Kids๐Ÿ Hobbyist
    Joined Aug 20263 posts17 pts๐Ÿ“ South Bay, CA
    Oct 29#11
    ESV - mixes clean, consistent on parameters. I use B-ionic so I like that I am keeping the brand consistent across the macro elements. I buy it when it goes on sale at BRS. The downside, and its a big hurdle for most, it is a 4 part mix.

    โ€” 135g mixed reef

  • @wsoldier
    ๐Ÿ˜Žย Coolย Kids๐ŸŒธPolyp Whisperer
    Joined Aug 202638 posts161 pts๐Ÿ“ Burbank, CA
    Oct 29#12
    I used both RS Blue bucket and RS black bucket for years with success. I switched over a year ago to Fritz Pro Reef Salt since it was cheaper and haven't had any issues yet.
  • @Drexl
    SCRM๐Ÿ˜Žย Coolย KidsโšกSPS Slinger
    Joined Aug 2026102 posts415 pts๐Ÿ“ Porter Ranch, CA
    Oct 30#13
    Tropic Marin Pro and no issues. I love that I can mix it within an hour (if not sooner) and use it right away. It usually mixes in the high 7's for alk, but if I need it a little higher, I just add a little soda ash to the bin before I shut off the mixing pump. I like that I can store it (tightly covered) and use it a week or two later and nothing has changed. Also, I believe TM make the Fauna Marin salt for them (I think that's what I read) but it's to Claude's specifications. The other benefit to TM Pro is, it's homogenized, so you don't have to mix the dry salt before use, not the case with IO, RC, etc. They also leave the nasty residue and precipitate alk/ca sometimes. The key with mixing any salt is using a big pump and mix in no more than half of the total amount at first, then slowly add the rest a cup at a time as soon as it clears. At least that's my method and it makes mixing really easy and there's no issues with precipitation. I used to use Salinity by Aqua Vitro (seachem) and I really liked that salt.

    โ€” Clams and acros

  • @janiners305
    SCRM๐Ÿ˜Žย Coolย Kids๐ŸŒธPolyp Whisperer
    Joined Aug 202675 posts307 pts๐Ÿ“ Glendora, CA
    ๐Ÿ”ง Build Contributor
    Oct 30#14
    Red Sea blue bucket. Only issue we have encountered is an almost new bucket turning rock solid in the garage. Was kept with the lid on, and no moisture in the garage, yet with the heat wave a few months back, it all turned into a rock of salt. With our measuring cup trapped inside. Put it in the sun for 3 days straight to try to loosen it up, and all we succeeded in doing was cracking the bucket itself.

    โ€” 105 gallon mixed reef - SPS/Torch/Goni

  • More in Water Chemistry

    • What salt is everyone using
      @toomuch420 ยท 3 replies ยท Nov 7
    • Red bug killer
      @ktran ยท 4 replies ยท Oct 18
    • Great vid about phosphate/phosphorus
      @Drexl ยท 16 replies ยท Oct 3
    • What is your pH and how to keep it above 8
      @IvanW ยท 14 replies ยท Oct 1
    • Whatโ€™s your salinity?
      @BackbayReef ยท 12 replies ยท Sep 23